Question:
What sets America apart from the rest of the world? Where does our greatness come from?
2007-09-29 08:37:42 UTC
In the year of our lord 2007 the United States faces a challenge we remain reluctant to recognizing in full and opportunities we fail to recognize at all. We are the greatest -and most virtuous- power in history. For now our existence is not at stake, although the lives of our citizens, the degree of our freedom and the well-being of our allies are at risk. There is no doubt that we will survive and triumph. But the decisions we make will determine the costs our enemies extract along the way. And we DO have enemies, old and new, merciless and uncompromising, who hate us for our success, our freedom, and our power, as well as for the global transformations we inspire.
The United States is cast in the role of a doctor during a plague. No matter how hopeless the situation may seem, the crisis demands our courage and perseverance. The risks we take are the only hope for avoiding a greater disaster for humanity. Despite the errors we have made in the middle east, the vitriol spit in our direction by the regions inhabitants isn't really about us, its about them. The middle east has grown so inhumane and weak that it craves a "great satan" to explain away its ineptitude. The greatest power on earth will have to do. Indeed the middle east remains the world's sick civilization. Because of our virtuous efforts, Iraq may become the Middle Easts beacon of liberty. Or it may end as another Arab pyre. The Iraqi's, not us, will determine their ultimate fate. Their choices will shape a civilizations future.

Of course there is much more to the world than the struggling Muslim heartlands. Europe is in the midst of an identity crisis of its own, haunted by a brutal past and insulted by Americas upstart success. The old powers are still far from forgiving us for supplanting them in the strategic arena - or for our generosity toward them in the last century. Had we only been as cruel as Europeans themselves in the wake of the twentieth century's great wars, we would be much better liked. The primary intellectual goal of Western European societies for the past half century has been to prove that the United States is as cruel and corrupt as they themselves have been. When your heritage is genocide, wars of aggression, or cowardly surrender, the record of the United States can be hard to bear. The old powers cannot avoid measuring themselves against us, but the disparities they discover are so great that europes moral delinquents cannot resist comforting themselves with lies about our naivete, our purported clumsiness, our violence and our crudity ( without pausing to ask themselves how such pathetic mediocrities could have built the richest, most powerful, most desirable and exemplary society in history). Indeed when it comes to self examination, the heartlands of Europe are simply the middle east lite.
Yet Europe is likely to be good for a number of surprises-surprising not the least to Europeans themselves. With our short historical memory (one American quality Germans welcome), we thoughtlessly accept that, since much of Europe appears to be passive, so it shall remain. But no continent has exported as much misery and slaughter as Europe has done, and chances are better than fair that Europe is simply catching its breath after the calamities it inflicted upon itself in the last century.
We last saw widespread pacifism just before 1914 and again during that half time break in that great European civil war that lasted until 1945 (or 1991 east of the Elbe).
Europes current round of playing pacifist dress up was enabled by Americas protection during the Cold War. We allowed our European wards to get away with a minimum number of chores. The United States did (and still does) the dirty work, seconded by our direct ancestor Britain. Even NATO merely obscured how little was asked of Europe. For almost a century the work of freedom and global security has been handled the great Anglo lateral alliance born of a struggle against tyranny of Continental European philosophies hatched on the Rhine and Danube. Our struggle continues today - against fanaticism and terror.
It is unlikely that Europe's present pacifism will last. Indeed, there are many different Europe's. The new Europe in the east understands that freedom has a price and cannot be purchased with appeasement. Southern Europe is undergoing a complex second renaissance. The United Kingdom, for all its grump resentment of the United States, will always align with us in a severe crisis: Our mutual values are far closer than any Briton shares with France or Germany. Anglo-American sparing can be vicious, but outsiders fail to grasp that it’s a family feud. And the family closes ranks to outsiders. France and Germany are Europes starkest problems (They are also vehemently anti-American). They wish to lead but lack the vision, power and generosity required to build enduring alliances. Germany and France are sick inside, having gobbled up immigrant populations they are unwilling and unable to digest. For all their fabulous criticism of American society ( where their calendars stop at around 1954), th extent of racism and bigotry in Continental Europe rivals that of a long gone American South and threatens to exceed it.
Meanwhile, "Old Europe" is rapidly becoming, truly, old Europe. With aging populations, bankrupt retirement systems, arthritic economies, educational stagnation and punitive taxation, it appears at first glance that the continent is headed for senility, for conditions under which its dwindling youth will neither be able to man the continents already enfeebled militaries nor support the overhang of the elderly.
Don’t bet on a weak, pacifist Europe doing nothing as the immigrant time bombs with explode, while demographic pressures stress its outer borders. Behind all the American scolding and empty swagger Europe is uncertain of its future. And afraid. And when Europe is uncertain and afraid, its impoverished immigrants and neighbors had better start worrying.
The most laughable predictions of the past two centuries have been those forecasting the decline of the West (especially the US). The formal empires may be gone, but the Anglo lateral world enjoys power, wealth and freedom without precedent, while continental Europe has never lived so safely or so well as under the Pax Americana. The last half century has been the most prosperous and peaceful in European history and Europeans don’t want the party to end. But its long past midnight. Europe can no longer afford the lavish social welfare systems it constructed over the decades while America paid the strategic bills without demur.
The trouble with Europe is of course, its dark side. If its racist populations feel sufficiently threatened by its Muslim millions within their divided societies and by terror exported from the Islamic heartlands, Europe my respond with a cruelty unimaginable to us today. After all, Europe is the continent that mastered ethnic cleansing and genocide after a thousand years of practice. We Americans my find ourselves in the unexpected position of confronting the Europe of tomorrow as we try to restrain its barbarities toward Muslims.

This should be the true American century where we move at last beyond the poisonous European divisions of the world and help create a genuine"new world order" - although not one based upon the murderous nonsense of the left.
America is the most revolutionary state and culture in history. Now its our turn to export revolution.

Since the end of the Cold War every conflict in which the United States has been involved has been to some degree a legacy of Europes colonial era - including the liberation of that frankenstein's monster of a country Iraq. We are cleaning up the messes left by Paris, Berlin and even London, while Europeans chide us self-righteously. We need to lead the world away from continental Europes cynical approach to human rights, which consists of theatrically mourning the dead but doing nothing to protect those still alive and threatened. Weakness never saved a human life!
In an age of global pessimism and fear, Americans still believe that change is not only possible, but likely to be good. Weather we wish it or not, we lead humanity. At times we will have to lead with bayonets,but, more often, we will lead through our ideas. If remain wise and just, as well as resolute, ever more of our fellow human beings will follow willingly.



And never forget, America is the worlds essential force for good. No amount of fashionable anti-Americanism will ever change that.
Seventeen answers:
2007-09-29 10:28:00 UTC
your greatness come from your stupidity...
whitequeenshirley
2007-09-29 14:53:09 UTC
Nothing sets us apart. Most Americans are deluded and lack a basic education/understanding of the world outside of America.



We actually believe the tinsel-town garbage and propaganda we are fed nightly on CBS/Fox. Politically we have no real choice - some rich right wing bastards or some other rich right wing bastards. We believe garbage like we can grow up to be President (providing of course we have countless millions).



We are arrogant but too ignorant to see it. We are racist, but deny it. I can say all of this because I've travelled in several countries and lived in both the UK and Germany, and both of those places I considered democratically superior with a better standard of living, more opportunity exists for the people there, through access to University education and Health Care. You've got to first see what others have elsewhere, before you can comment on what you have here.
Coasty
2007-09-29 09:01:33 UTC
America is where the ideas of individual freedoms and responsibility coalesced from pie in the sky to reality. The thing that makes America great is not a single thing but a group of ideas. These ideas can be found expressed in a number of places. The Declaration of Independence, the Common Sense Pamphlets, the Constitution, the Virginia Bill of Rights among others. What is about to tear America down is the fact that to many people have demanded the right to exercise their rights but refuse to exercise their responsibility. One without the other is a sure prescription for disaster and the loss of greatness for America!
2007-09-29 09:45:20 UTC
America is set apart mainly by its arrogance and its stupidity.

No other nation can match the level of ignorance and selfishness set by the good old U S of A.

Another thing that America excel at is hypocrisy.

Oh yeh wait a minute...you are an rrrrrrrr sole.
?
2007-09-29 08:57:47 UTC
I feel what makes America great is the freedom to become what a person want to be. If, people would research their heritage, they will find, we are not from America. We come from many countries around the world. This diverse culture also affects our language. Look up the Etymology of many of our words. What has happened, many people were hindered in their creative abilities in other countries. When they came to America, they were able to expound on their area of expertise. We have everything from pizza to wine. Some of which have won world recognition. From cars to motorcycles, people from around the world have come to America to build an economic empire that really is the world itself. Dutch, German, African, Polish, French, the list seems to include every nation or a big part of them. So, if people can see my concept of America, we see what makes America great; is the people.
Buying is Voting
2007-09-29 08:42:21 UTC
"Greatness?" What does that mean, specifically, and according to whom? There's a lot about the U.S. and the Americas as a whole that I find to be quite great. You might disagree with me about those things being great.



For example, what sets us apart economically is our unbending free market pursuit of the biggest buck. I don't think that makes us great though. I have different standards.



Free speech, as noted above, is something I think makes the country great. As soon as free speech is stifled in the name of security, we are a dead nation. Literally. Read up on the Military Commissions Act, for example, and how close that is bringing us to our loss of liberty. This is the idea on which movies and stories like the Matrix, V for Vendetta, etc. or books such as Orwell's 1984, are based.
Hilary
2016-03-19 06:16:09 UTC
God is the author (beginner and finisher) of our lives, yet he gives us free will. He does not force us to follow His principles. He loves us too much to force anything on us. As a Catholic, we believe God knows our best interests at heart. Still, sometimes things we do or dont do cause us to leave the will of God and that is when fate turns. Keep in mind, however, that God is omnipresent and omnipotent, and He will allow things to happen (fate?) for a life lesson or to reprimand us. Good luck and God bless.
CHRISTOPHER K
2007-09-29 09:41:16 UTC
The ideals that have become the essence of America go back to the writings of Thomas Paine (Common Sense), Thomas Jefferson/Alexander Hamilton/John Jay (The Federalist Papers), Adam Smith (The Wealth of Nations), and Alexis De Tocqueville.

I will list what, I feel, are the things that make us great.



1.) Individual freedom- We, as Americans, maintain the existence of citizen liberties (as oppossed to liberties for illegals) that include freedom of speech (which is threatened by the misguided notion of freedom of expression), freedom of religion (not from religion), freedom to assemble, freedom to pursue happiness (meaning a career and right of land ownership), the right to vote for whomever we want to, and the freedom to petition our government for a redress of any grievances. With individual freedoms, however, comes responsibility. It is up to you to decide how far we have strayed from this idea of 'rugged American individualism'.



2.) capitalism- (I know there are neo-Marxists out there right now squirming with contempt at this notion). No system of economics is better suited and preserves the nature of democracy than capitalism. The brilliance of a supply and demand economy unfettered by the intrusiveness of government (what Adam Smith called 'laissez-faire') is unsurpassed by any other option. The attempt by an individual citizen to do what is economically best for him or his family inadvertently results in the creation of a 'greater good' effect. When government gets involved (i.e. Socialism) it does what is best for it's own self preservation and political goals, thus sacrificing the needs of the people. Supply and demand cannot function effectively against governmental greed.



3.) Belief in God- We are a nation that was founded by men who believed in God and applied the virtues of the Judaic-Christian legacy of Western civilization. To ignore this influence is to thus cast aside what it is we stand for. I believe that a citizen can be atheist or of a differing faith, but they must appreciate the religious heritage that has given them the freedom to live as they do.



4.) Representative government- I think this speaks for itself.



5.) National sovereignty- unlike the EU or the former USSR, the United States still upholds the belief that it has the right to act for its' own national interests.
2014-08-05 17:05:55 UTC
Hello,

I'm following a system to improve my vision with simple eye exercises. I found it on this site http://www.goobypls.com/r/rd.asp?gid=413. I'm starting seeing very positive (and unexpected) results.

It's a very good program and easy to use.
tarzanmanofthejungle
2007-09-29 08:52:13 UTC
I'm not sure if we are necessarily greater than the rest of the world, but I sure love our Constitution, even though it has been trashed by politicians for the last 150 years.
jim h
2007-09-29 09:17:00 UTC
It used to be our national pride , the belief that everyone in the community should look after one another and our moral standards. However in the last 30 years our moral standards have been on a steady decline and that in turn has destroyed our communities.
jrldsmith
2007-09-29 08:48:51 UTC
Not being stuck in a class struggle. The freedom to make oneself great through hard work and ablility.
B. D Mac
2007-09-29 09:24:45 UTC
Arrogance
?
2007-09-29 08:40:44 UTC
Free speech.

Hard to hide mistakes and lies in the light of that.



The day we silence our critics is the harbinger of our demise.
2007-09-29 08:45:40 UTC
America has only been around for 300 years... how long have other countries been around?
bobanalyst
2007-09-29 08:41:34 UTC
The understanding of the U. S. Constitution and the willingness to defend it.
dcrc93
2007-09-29 08:51:13 UTC
GOD


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...