Question:
Should America have a second revolution?
scrubb201kt
2006-07-05 13:37:15 UTC
I'm not advocating violence or anything. However I don't think there will be any other way to take America back, from the corrupt big government and huge corporations, than a bloody revolution. Am I just totaly wrong?
Sixteen answers:
madbaldscotsman
2006-07-05 13:41:12 UTC
We don't need any stinking revolutions because we can vote every four years. If you don't like the candidates, you have to right to nominate anyone you want.
jpj
2006-07-05 14:02:58 UTC
You are not totally wrong. In fact you are most emphatically correct. However, you are a bit late. We already had one. And if you have any doubts as to the validity of self- determination, read the Declaration of Independence. Humans have inalienable rights to govern themselves. And in the event that the Federal government does not do what we the people set it up to do, it is our right and responsibilty to abolish it. And we did...well, we tried. It is called the War for Southern Independence, commonly mis-labeled as the Civil War. The trial of this right, however, was settled by wager of battle. The Jeffersonian, constitutionalist, states-righters lost. The revolution failed. And as a result, the United STATES of America were reconstituted into a new Nationalized EMPIRE of America. Our federal government is out of control. In fact, there is only one small strand of fabric standing between total domination. And that strand is the second amendment, soon to be eroded away.
Truth
2006-07-05 13:56:39 UTC
Yes, and its happening right now.

A revolution is defined as 'revolving' a situation, 180 degrees.



Right now the Republicans control the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government.



However, even the conservative Supreme Court has upheld flag burning as a legitimate form of protest. Conservative justice Scalia even ruled in its favor.



Democrats are sure to win the legislature back in November, because the war is depleting our resources and gas will continue to escalate in price.



People vote from the dinner table, and don't get it when an oilman president can't control the A) cost of gasoline and B) the profit margins of oil companies, which Bush defends because he's in their back pockets.



Really, its time for him and the republicans to step aside and let democrats restore our economy.
d.benton_smith
2006-07-11 14:02:43 UTC
Whether or not we do have a revolution has little or nothing to do with if we should. Historically, all civilizations go utterly mad every few hundred years or so and therefore it is reasonable to expect that ours will, too.



But I do have this to say:



Revolutions are bad. They tend to engender and empower a type of leadership that is talented at general mayhem and brutally deficient in justice. Those are the leaders who will sit in power after the smoke clears and blood dries.



Do what you can to make your own life and the lives of those around you better. Don't contemplate killing people.



Heaven forbid that one succeeds in violent revolution only to discover that one has become the very thing that one hated.
ebskinner1
2006-07-05 14:02:41 UTC
Yes we need a revolution. It was stated as fact by Thomas Jefferson, that whenever the gov. gets to big or corrupt and they stop representing the people and just themselves that WE THE PEOPLE must have a revolution.

Democracy is a fragile gov. And in being so must walk a fine line from becoming corrupt.To many Big names and corporations are throwing their weight and mostly their money to blind everyone and put aside our CIVIL LIBERTIES for their benefit.So they can do and say as they please and get away with it.

Anymore I welcome the thought of a Revolution.Maybe one day my kids will have the same civil liberties that I had, Once Upon a Time............
Coach D.
2006-07-05 13:43:31 UTC
Yes - unfortunately - you are "totally wrong". What exactly are you wanting. We have a great country where 300 million live. We have the strongest military and the greatest form of government. We have free elections where people can choose who will lead. We have a great economy and the lowest unemployment. Our economy is booming, inflation is down and people are living longer that ever. What are you missing? You need to get your news from someplace other than the Daily Show or Air America.
mel18
2006-07-05 15:26:45 UTC
well I would say vote, but look what happened in 2000, I think in the next 50to 100 years or so, the united states economy and government will collapse, and there will at least a social revoltuion, I'm not sure if there will be a violent revoution or civil war though, that is of course, if the world still exist in the next 50 years
Ray W
2006-07-05 14:09:54 UTC
No need for human-sacrifice.



If the American people want to live in freedom then they’re going to have to return to expressing the founding principles of American freedom. This would automatically lose the corporate mockery of democracy.



Each and every individual must learn to abide by and convey the inherent, "Laws of Nature and of Nature's God, "self-evident" truth and the people's "unalienable Rights", endowed by their Creator. "That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men…", as mandated by the American Declaration of Independence.



Today, without individually expressing the founding principles of American freedom, Americans, and their legacy of freedom and prosperity, are being devalued into warriors and debt slaves.
siropson
2006-07-05 13:43:11 UTC
I think most people are comfortable with the way things are. Some mumble and grumble but most don't want to do anything to change it. So even if a revolution was the answer, I highly doubt you could convince enough people to do it.
aplusjimages
2006-07-05 13:42:13 UTC
I think there should definitely be a consumer revolution. In fact it has already started. Check out http://www.pirate-party.us. It's about fighting such problems in America. Its good to hear that more people are getting pissed off by this issue.
?
2016-11-01 10:24:45 UTC
i'm nevertheless hopeful that the rustic ought to correctly be reformed from interior of. yet, now, yet another Constitutional convention may not be a nasty theory! enable's upload yet another couple of branches of authorities and some extra assessments and balances even as we are at it. i imagine we choose a governmental branch dedicated to assistance dissemination, corresponding to the function of the loose press yet to boot such as medical analyze and education. Plus we choose yet another branch with someone on the helm, someone we may call an Ombudsman, whose purpose should be to help each and every human being in operating by using the distinctive layers of forms which have grown up round all the different branches. we ought to revote on multiple aspects of the unique structure, too, plus each and every of the amendments. enable's analyze the bill of Rights and make certain, once and for all, if we fairly choose that excellent to undergo fingers -- and could it or ought to it not be tied to the existence of a electorate' military (and what the heck is that, besides?). we ought to placed on the table different contentious difficulty of our time like the continually proposed and not in any respect ratified equivalent excellent change, too. What say you? are you able to imagine of different significant themes lets opt to in ordinary words bypass ahead and make certain as a replace of wandering lower backward and forward, round and around the timber in each and every election?
2006-07-05 13:51:09 UTC
We voted our government in.



There are two reasons the liberals would get their @sses handed to them in a revolution:



1. They are the minority

2. They don't have any guns.
meisa777
2006-07-05 14:10:17 UTC
People do not revolt unless times are bad enough. Times are not bad enough for people to revolt. The majority of people in the U.S. have what they feel is necessary for life. You will get some small groups who might protest, but not enough to entitle a full revolution.
-RKO-
2006-07-05 14:12:45 UTC
Voting isn't the answer. First of all, we don't "have the right to nominate anybody we want"; a political party does that for us, with little input from the general public.



Politicians prefer low voter turn-outs. It increases their chances of getting re-elected so they con continue to suck off the taxpayers' teat, enriching themselves with lavish salaries, outlandish cost-of-living increases, all-expense-paid luxury vacations, and unimaginable health, medical and retirement benefits.



Besides, if you vote all the rotten Republicans out of office, you only replace them with rotten Democrats.



Actually you SHOULD be advocating violence, because that's the only thing that will make any difference.



The U.S. Constitution gives us the right to bear arms against a tyrranical, oppressive government. Thomas Jefferson once said: "The TREE OF LIBERTY must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants."



___________________________________________________

Check out the new blog book: BUSHWACKER!

www.blogger.com

http://al-aback.blogspot.com

___________________________________________________



Consider for a moment what the Bush administration has done since 2000, in collusion with the most evil, corrupt, incompetent Congress ever to occupy the Capitol Building:



1. Illegally and unconstitutionally invaded another sovereign nation that in no way threatened, provoked, or attacked the United States;

2. Massacred tens of thousands of Iraqi citizens, including women and children, for no justifiable reason;

3. Tortured 'detainees' in direct violation of the rules of the Geneva Convention, and condoned physical, psychological, verbal, emotional and sexual abuse;

4. Turned America into a police state wherein citizens are presumed guilty until proven innocent;

5. Initiated failed economic policies that will result in a severe depression right after Bush leaves office (so they can blame it on the Democrats);

6. Drowned American taxpayers in trillions of dollars of debt;

7. Tarnished our reputation as a world leader and global peacekeeper;

8. Terrified other nations into developing their own nuclear weapons as their defense against the world's newest 'evil empire' - the United States of America;

9. Neglected America's homeless, hungry, poor, disadvantaged, disabled, underprivileged, sick and unemployed while playing "Robin Hood in Reverse", stealing from the poor and giving it all to rich elitists, lobbyists, special interest groups and big corporations who - in turn - make generous (if not illegal) campaign contributions to ensure the GOP remains in power;

10. Killed more than 2, 500 U.S. soldiers (so far).



Yes, AMERICAN SHOULD HAVE A SECOND REVOLUTION!



But there's a problem: we're preoccupied with trivial stuff such as our maxxed-out credit cards; $3.00-a-gallon fuel for our $60,000 SUVs; Britney Spears' love life; Jacko's pedophilia; professional landscaping for our $350,000 home; "low prices - everyday" at WalMart for junk we don't even need; and the latest rankings of our favorite baseball team.



Until we begin to take an active, involved interest in the political system, nothing will change.



Until we get off the couch, put down the remote, and begin to FIGHT to take our country back, nothing will change. The U.S. Constitution gives us the RIGHT to bear arms against a tyrannical, oppressive governemnt; that was one of the main reasons our founding fathers fought the first American Revolution.



Instead, we're like lobsters languishing in a pot of lukewarm water. Until the water reaches a boiling point, we'll remain 'comfortable' and uninclined to start screaming. By the time the water's boiling us beet-red, we'll be screaming in agony about our apathy. Then it will be too late...



America's biggest creditor is China. Within a generation, our grand-children or great-grand-children will see America turn into a two-tiered social class, similar to those in Haiti and the Dominican Republic. There will be a handful of the very, very rich - and (the rest of us) the very, very poor. And, once our fiscally-challenged society can no longer afford an army, China will simply "call in its chips" and take our assets, real estate, OIL, and all other natural resources.



We have totally ignored the environmental issues facing this country and the world. Apparently, our 'Christian nation' doesn't believe that God (or whatever you prefer to call such an intelligent designer) saw the need to protect and preserve the delicate balance between human beings, plants, and all other animals on Earth. So, when the rainforests are all gone because McDonalds needs more grazing land for its cattle to sell you more cheap BigMacs, there might also be a tiny little frog or spider whose genes carry the cure for cancer. But we'll never know, because we've destroyed that insignificant little animal.



And when global warming causes tidal waves and massive flooding in big cities along both coasts of both oceans, we'll all sit around and say, "Duh...what happened?"



And when the Earth runs out of OIL and coal our descendants will have to resort back to living in the dark once the sun goes down.



And if we keep asphalting over all the rich farmland in this country to make way for glitzy shopping malls or luxury condos, farmers won't be able to grow crops. So we won't be able to eat. So we will DIE.



And if the OIL companies are allowed to disrupt the patterns of ocean life, including coral reef (which is a marine animal, by the way) and disturb the caribou's migration areas, it will mean the end of many ocean-going animals (which means you might not enjoy shrimp cocktails ot tuna casseroles anymore) and small Eskimo civilizations will be eradicated from the planet.



Should America have a second revolution?



You bet! And it needs to happen NOW! -RKO- 07/05/06
hazegrey
2006-07-05 14:10:25 UTC
GREAT ? YES BUT WE WOULD LOSE. POLICE AND GUARD WOULD KILL THERE OWN PEOPLE. WHAT ABOUT THIS, IF WE MAKE OUR OWN MONEY WHY ARE WE IN DEBT ?

WE SHOULD PROFIT FROM OUR MONEY NOT BORROW IT!

1 DOLLAR BILL IS NOT WORTH 1 DOLLAR, MORE LIKE 50 CENTS.

I LOVE AMERICA BUT I THINK ITS TO LATE TO SAVE OUR COUNTRY.

WERE TO DIVIDED.

GOD BLESS AMERICA
rhyasr
2006-07-05 13:48:59 UTC
NOOOOO!! we the people control the gov. let's just get out and

VOTE


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...